01 / The shortlist
How do you build a comparable shortlist?
Begin with factories whose existing equipment and process match the product, rather than sending a vague request to every directory listing. Give the same brief to each supplier and ask the same initial questions: legal entity, production address, core process, current categories, intended subcontractors, minimum order, realistic monthly capacity and timing for a sample. Request the name of the person who will own the project after a purchase order is signed. The most impressive sales representative is not always the production owner.
A founder should distinguish a manufacturer from a trader or aggregator without assuming that one is always worse. A trader may coordinate several factories well, but the agreement must identify who makes the goods, who carries quality liability and who controls changes. If a bidder will not identify the production site, price and timeline cannot be evaluated with the same confidence as a direct factory offer.
| Evidence | What to verify | Why it matters |
|---|---|---|
| Factory identity | Address, legal entity, named production contact | Know who makes and remedies the goods |
| Process fit | Equipment, materials and examples in the category | Avoid learning on your first batch |
| Commercial fit | MOQ, lead time, exclusions and payment terms | Compare cash and delivery risk |
02 / The record
Which credentials can actually be verified?
Ask for the licence that applies to the exact product and production premises. For food, the public FoSCoS facility can help verify FSSAI registration or licence information. For a product under mandatory BIS certification, inspect the relevant product scope and current order. A logo on a brochure, an expired PDF or a licence belonging to another unit is weaker evidence than a verifiable record tied to the site that will produce your batch.
Credentials do not establish that a factory can meet your specification. Request recent test reports for comparable products, an outline of incoming-material checks, in-process controls and finished-goods release. During a visit, ask an operator to show how a defect is recorded and traced. If the answer lives only in a presentation, design a pilot with independent inspection before committing to a large order.
03 / The pilot
What should a trial batch prove?
A sample tests a possible product. A pilot batch tests a repeatable system. Ask the factory to use the intended production line, packaging, input suppliers and quality checks, then record the yield, defects, time spent and deviation from the approved sample. Inspect the beginning, middle and end of the run where practical. Observe whether a supervisor can stop work when a specification is missed and whether corrective action is documented.
Ship some pilot units through the actual channel. A cosmetic item may survive a shelf but leak in courier delivery; an electronics accessory may work on a bench yet fail after a week of customer use. The founder should log returns and complaints by batch, not just ask whether the factory considered the order complete. A manufacturer that helps diagnose a defect is more valuable than one that only replaces visibly broken units.
- Production-line sample
- Recorded yield and defect categories
- Transit and customer-use test
- Named corrective-action owner
04 / The decision
How should you compare price with risk?
Score suppliers on a weighted sheet before seeing the final price if possible. Give meaningful weight to product fit, repeatability, compliance scope, communication, lead-time reliability, change control and remedies. Keep price visible, but do not let it erase a weak quality result. A low unit quote can be overwhelmed by rejected stock, missed campaign dates, emergency freight and founder time spent on rework.
A strong supplier relationship is not an unconditional promise of trust. Agree who approves material substitutions, who owns tooling and artwork, how forecasts are shared, and when either party can exit. Unilever's Partner to Win programme describes collaborative improvement with strategic suppliers; a small brand can borrow the discipline of clear goals and mutual feedback while retaining a second-source plan for critical inputs.